Abstract

 As part of the Arab-Palestinian minority, uniquely defined by political history rather than immigration, this group navigates complex cultural, social, and personal dilemmas when entering Israeli academic spaces and encountering Jewish society. Employing a qualitative case study, the research analyzed reflections from 16 Bedouin students  in a second-year education program who participated in a course involving mixed Arab-Jewish group work. Findings revealed feelings of "intercultural personal struggle" and "intercultural distress", reflecting a dynamic tension between a need for distance (often linked to the political context) and a strong desire for closeness, open dialogue, and learning the other's culture. Attitudes toward a pedagogy of intercultural sensitivity varied, from passive reliance on institutional initiatives or lecturer guidance to an investigative point of view recognizing specific qualities and tools of this pedagogy. Key barriers identified included language difficulties (especially Hebrew for Arab students) and physical and cultural distance resulting from demographic separation. The study noted that unmediated meetings could lead to cultural judgment and that mere joint presence in an academic space was insufficient for creating closeness. Drawing on these findings, the study proposes a six-step educational model for fostering continuous intercultural care. This model emphasizes learning the other's culture, addressing historical inequality (specifically demographic and educational injustice), developing consciousness that "intercultural distance is manipulated" for responsible interaction, relevant coursework, and practical projects. It accounts for the group's complex, dynamic identity and conflictual reality, suggesting future educators require training in both intercultural closeness and the ability to take responsible distance when necessary.

Keywords

  • Integration
  • Education for Multiculturalism
  • interculturalism
  • intercultural caring
  • intercultural distress
  • personal intercultural struggle

References

  1. Abu-Asba, H. & Kenan, E. (2015). Arab education and multiculturalism, in: Arrear, H. and E. Kenan (eds.), Identity, narrative and multiculturalism in Arab education in Israel (pp. 117-137), Or Yehuda: Pardes.
  2. Abu - Saad, I. (2014). State - Directed ‘Development’ as a Tool for Dispossessing the Indigenous Palestinian Bedouin Arabs in the Negev. In: M. Turner & O. Shweiki (Eds). Decolonizing Palestinian Political Economy: De - development and Beyond (PP. 138 – 157). London: Palgrave Macmillan.
  3. Abu Saad, I. (2010). The Arabs of the Negev: past, present, and future challenges. Be'er Sheva: Ben-Gurion University of the Negev.
  4. Abu Saad, I. (2011). Arab education in Israel and the control policy. Beer Sheva: Ben-Gurion University of the Negev.
  5. Abu-Saad, I. (2023). The Bedouin Arab education system in the Negev in a local view - reality and needs. The Israel Institute for Democracy.
  6. Agbaria, A. & Tutri, M. (2016). Multiculturalism will not survive on good will alone: Arab students in colleges for training for teaching in Hebrew education. In: J. Yonah., C. Ben Porat & B. Bashir (Eds). Public policy and multiculturalism (pp. 39 – 68). Ra'anana: Van Leer Institute: The United Kibbutz.
  7. Allan, R. & Hill, B. (1995). Multicultural Education in Australia: Historical Development and Current Status. In J. A. Banks & C. A. M. Banks (Eds.), Handbook of Research on Multicultural Education (pp. 763-777). New York: Macmillan.
  8. Armento, B., Thomas, C. & Causey, V. (2000). Cultural Diversity is Basically Foreign Term to me: The Challenges of Diversity for Preservice Teacher Education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 16: 33 – 45.
  9. Avinon, Y. (2013). Cooperative learning. Hed Hachinuch, 87(5): 92-93.
  10. Ball, A. F. (2006). Multicultural Strategies for Education and Social Change. New York: Teacher College Press.
  11. Banks, J. A. (1995). Multicultural education: Its effects on students racial
  12. and gender role attitudes. In J. A. Banks & C. A. M. Banks (Eds.), Handbook of research on multicultural education (pp. 617 – 627). New York, NY: Macmillan Publishing.
  13. Banks, J. A. (2004). Handbook of research on multicultural education.
  14. Banks, J. A. (2015). Cultural Diversity and Education. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
  15. Bennett, M. (2013). Basic concepts of intercultural communication: Paradigms, principles, and practices. Hachette UK.
  16. Bennett, C. (1995). Preparing Teachers for Cultural Diversity and Standards of Academic Excellence. Journal of Teacher Education, 46: 259 – 266.
  17. Bhargava, A., Hawley, L.D., Scott, C. L. Stien, M. & Phekps, A. (2004). 'An Investigation of Student Perception of Multicultural Education Experience in School of Education'. Multicultural Education, 11 (4): 18 – 25.
  18. Boymel, J. (2011). the military government. In: A. Saba' - Khoury & N.
  19. Rohana (eds.), The Palestinians in Israel: Essays in Politics and Society in history (pp. 45 – 55). Haifa: Meda El-Carmel.
  20. Buber, M. (1980). I-Am You: Examinations in Anthropological Philosophy. Bialik Institution.
  21. Carmon, A. (2016). Outlines for a comprehensive Educational Concept for the School in the 21st century. In Sh. Beck (ed.). Information, Knowledge, and Opinion - the DNA of Education (pp. 31 - 70). Ra'anana: Mofet Institute.
  22. Charmaz, K. (1995) Grounded Theory. In: J. Smith., R. Harré, and L. Langenhove. Eds), Rethinking Methods in Psychology (pp. 27 – 65). Sage: London.)
  23. Clement, G. (1996). Care, Autonomy and Justice: Feminist and Ethic of Care. Boulder CO: Westview Press.
  24. Coulby, D. (2006). Intercultural Education and Theory and Practice. Intercultural Education, 17 (3): 245 – 257.
  25. Diab, K. & Mi'ari, M. (2007). Collective Identity & Readiness for Relations with Jews among Palestinian Arab Students at David Yalin Teacher Training College in Israel. Intercultural Education 18(5): 427 – 444.
  26. Eilat-Yaguri, T. (2008). Human Dialogue with the Absolute: Kierkegaard's Ladder to the summit of spiritual existence. Magnes.
  27. Eldering, L. (1996). Multicultural Education in International Perspective. Anthropology & Educational Quarterly, 27 (3): 315 – 330.
  28. Elior, R. (2000). Education for culture in a multicultural society, In: M. Barlev., N. Gober & Y.M. Korah Lang (Eds.), Education for culture in a multicultural society - issues in teacher training (pp. 41 - 50). Jerusalem: The Hebrew University.
  29. Elsana, M. (2021). Indigenous Land Rights in Israel: A Comparative Study of the Bedouin. New York: Routledge.
  30. Falah, G. (1989). Israeli State Policy toward Bedouin Sedentarization in the Negev. Journal of Palestine Studies 18(2): 71 – 91.
  31. Feuerstein, R., Falik, L. & Feuerstein, R. S. (2015). Changing minds and brains. New York, NY: Teachers College Columbia University.
  32. Figueroa, P. (1995). Multicultural Education in the United Kingdom: Historical Development and Current Status. In J. A. Banks & C. A. M. Banks (Eds.), Handbook of Research on Multicultural Education (pp. 778-800). New York: Macmillan.
  33. Flavian, H. (2020). The shared classroom space and its contribution to differential teaching-learning processes. in a Powell-Benjamin and R. Rheingold (Eds), shared spaces in the system in education and academia (pp. 239-249). Ra'anana: Moft Institute.
  34. Fraser, N. (2014). A dispute for recognition? Dilemmas of justice in the "post- socialist" era. In D. Filak and A. Ram (eds), The rule of capital - Israeli society in the global Era (p. 290 -296). Jerusalem and Tel Aviv: Van Leer Institute and the United Kibbutz.
  35. Ghanem, A. & Khatib, M. (2017). The Nationalisation of The Israeli Ethnocratic Regime and the Palestinian Minority's Shrinking Citizenship. Citizenship Studies, 21: 861 – 871.
  36. Gardner, H. (2011). Frames of mind: The theory of multiple intelligences. New York, NY: Basic Books.
  37. Gat, O. (2023). Action research: A workshop for education for shared life: Bedouins, and Jews female teaching students at Kay College for Education in the southern Region of Israel. OJER Open Journal for Education Research, 7 (2): 107 – 132.
  38. Gat, O. (2023). Attitudes towards intercultural closeness: before and after, learning as part of an academic course and performing a joint assignment in mixed groups: Bedouin Muslim students and Jewish students at a teacher training college in the south of the State of Israel. Journal of Multiculturalism Education, 9.
  39. Gay, G. (1995). 'Curriculum Theory and Multicultural Education', in: J. A. Banks and C. A. M. Banks (Eds), Handbook of Research on Multicultural Education. New York: MacMillan Publishing.
  40. Gilligan, C. (1993). In a different voice: Psychological theory and women’s development. Harvard University Press.
  41. Gilligan, C. (2008). Boys and the American Education System: A Biocultural Review of the Literature. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry 10, (2): 80 – 95.
  42. Gilligan, K. (2016). To Join the Resistance. Hakibbutz Hameuhad.
  43. Guyton, E. M. & Wesche, M.V. (2005). The Multicultural Efficacy Scale: Development, Item Selection, and Reliability. Multicultural Perspectives, 7 (4): 21 – 29.
  44. Gophnik, A. (1993). How we know our minds: The illusion of first-person knowledge of intentionality. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 16: 1 – 14.
  45. Heidegger, M (1996). Being and Time, trans. Joan Stambaugh Albany: State University of New York Press.
  46. Held, V. (2006). The ethics of care: Personal, political, and global. Oxford University Press on Demand.
  47. Ho - Kyung, H. Seong Woo, C. & Ju Sung, J. (2015). Relationships among multicultural sensitivity, multicultural education awareness, and level of multicultural education practice of South Korea. KEDI Journal of Educational Policy, 12 (1), 107 – 126.
  48. Kennan, I. (2014). Knowledge as Responsibility: Universities and Society. Journal of Higher Education, Outreach & Engagement, 18(2): 178 – 206.
  49. Kierkegaard, S. (1985). Philosophical fragments (HV Hong & EH Hong, Eds. and Trans. Princeton: Princeton UP. Koppelman, K. (2011). The Great Diversity Debate: Embracing Pluralism in School and Society. Teachers College Press.
  50. Kymlicka, W. (1989). Liberalism, Community, and Culture. Oxford University Press.
  51. Lamm, Z. (1999). Cultural pluralism as a multifaceted and multicultural ideology in Israeli society. Ramat Gan: Ben Ilan University.
  52. Lamm, Z. (2000). Multicultural, Intercultural Education, Is It for Real?. In M. Bar Lev (Ed.), Teaching Culture in a Multicultural Society, Issues in Teacher Continuing Education, Collection 9 (pp. 27 – 76). Jerusalem: Hebrew University, School of Education, and Ministry of Education and Culture.
  53. Lazaridou, A., George S. & Polymeropoulou, V. (2020). Interculturalism and Social Justice: The Case of the Inclusion of Chinese Children in Greek Schools. Handbook of Social Justice Interventions in Education: 1-23.
  54. Lustick, I. (1980). Arabs in the Jewish State: Israel’s Control of a National Minority. Austin: University of Texas Press.
  55. Ma'ri, S. (1978). Arab Education in Israel. Syracuse Press University.
  56. Marx, E. (1967). Bedouin of the Negev. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
  57. McIntyre, A. (1997). Making meaning of whiteness: Exploring racial identity with white teachers. New York, NY: State University of New York Press.
  58. Mizrahi, N. (2017). Sociology in Israel to where? From a sociology of suspicion to a sociology of meaning. Megamot, 51(2), 69-114.
  59. Nieto, S. (1992). Affirming Diversity Sociopolitical Context of Multicultural Education. N. Y: Longham.
  60. Nakhleh, K. (1979). Palestinian Dilemma: Nationalist Consciousness Education University in Israel. Shrewsbury.
  61. Nisbett R., E. & Wilson, T. D. (1977). Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes. Psychological Review, 84(3): 231-259.
  62. Noddings, N. (2002). Starting at home: Caring and social policy. Univ of California Press.
  63. Noddings, N. (2007). When a School Reform Goes Wrong. New York: Teachers College Press.
  64. Noddings, N. (2013). Caring: A relational approach to ethics and moral education. Univ of California Press.
  65. Norberg, K. (2000). Intercultural education and teacher education in Sweden. Teaching and teacher education 16(4): 511-519.
  66. Perry, P. (2007). Education in a multicultural society. Carmel. Powell-Benyamin, A. and Rheingold, R. (2016). Multiculturalism in teacher training institutions: between consolidated policy for local initiatives. In B. Bashir, C. Ben Porat and V. Yona (eds), Public policy and multiculturalism (pp. 39-68). Jerusalem and Tel Aviv: Van Leer Institute and the united kibbutz.
  67. Rapel, D. (2000). Education for culture in a multicultural society. in m. Barlev (Ed). Education for culture in a multicultural society, issues in teacher training (file 9), Jerusalem: The Hebrew University.
  68. Rosen, Y. and Perkins, D. (2013). Shallow roots require constant watering: The challenge of sustained impact in educational programs. International Journal of Higher Education, 2 (4): 91 – 100.
  69. Samuha, S. (2005). Index of Jewish-Arab relations in Israel. Haifa: University Haifa, Friedrich Ebert Foundation, Arab Jewish Center, and Forum for Consensus Socially.
  70. Savage, M., Alan, W. & Devine, F. (2005). Capitals, assets, and resources: some critical issues 1. The British journal of sociology 56(1): 31-47.
  71. Shhada, N. (2001). The effect of university higher education on identity The Arab students in Israel. M.A. thesis: The Hebrew University in Jerusalem.
  72. Shkedi, A. (2007). Words that try to touch: Qualitative research: Theory and application. Ramot.
  73. Shlesky, S. & Alpert, B. (2007). Ways in writing qualitative research: from deconstructing reality to constructing it as a text. Mofet Institute.
  74. Schlein, C. & Garii, B. (2011). Cross - cultural interpretations of curricular contextual crossings. Issues in Teacher Education, 20 (2), 81 – 94
  75. Sleeter, C. E. (2001). Preparing teachers for culturally diverse schools: Research and overwhelming presence of whiteness. Journal of Teacher Education, 52 (2), 94 – 106
  76. Smith, S. (2013). (Almost) Everything I need to know about multiculturalism
  77. I learned on jury duty. Multicultural Education, 20 (2), 40 – 42.
  78. Strauss, A. & Corbin, I. (1990). Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques. London: Sage Publications.
  79. Strauss, A. & Glaser, B. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. Mill Valley, CA: Sociology Press.
  80. Suleiman, R. (2002). Perceptions of Collective Identity and Voting Behavior: The Case of the Palestinians in Israel. Journal of Social Psychology, 142(6): 753 – 766.
  81. Swirski, S. & Hasson, Y. (2006). Invisible Citizens: Israel Government Policy toward the Negev Bedouin. Beer Sheva: Negev Center for Regional Development, Ben - Gurion University of the Negev.
  82. Tamir, Y. (1998). Two concepts of multiculturalism. In: R. Shamir and A. Sagi (Eds.), Multiculturalism in a Democratic and Jewish State. Ra'anana: Ramot.
  83. Ulkpokodu, N. (2002). Breaking through Preservice Teachers Disposition a Multicultural Education Course U: A Practice. Multicultural Education 9(3): 25 – 33.
  84. Walzer, M. (1992). "Comment" Multiculturalism and the Politics of Recognition. Princeton University Press.
  85. Weissblai, E. (2006). Children in the Bedouin sector in the Negev - a snapshot The Knesset, Research, and Information Center.
  86. Weissblai, E. (2017). Education in the Bedouin society in the Negev - a snapshot. The Knesset, Research and Information Center.
  87. Woodson, C. G. (1990). The Mis-education of the Negro. Trenton. NJ: Africa World Press.
  88. Weil, S. & George A. P. (1977). The Simone Weil Reader. Mt Kisco, NY Moyer Bell Limited.
  89. Yona, Y. (1998). The state of all its citizens, a nation state, or a multicultural democracy? Israel and the Limits of Liberal Democracy. Alpaim, 16: 238-263.
  90. Yogev, A. (2001). Approaches to a value society in a pluralistic society. In: J. Iram, S. Shkolnikor & A. Schechter (Eds). Junction, values, and education in Israeli society (pp. 355 – 379). Jerusalem: Office of the Chief Scientist.
  91. Yona, Y. (2007). Multicultural education in Israel: challenges and difficulties. In: P. Perry (editor), Education in a multicultural society: pluralism and meeting points between cultural divides (pp. 39-67). Jerusalem: Carmel.
  92. Zimmerman, M. (2005). 'The idea of the university, science and the state in a historical perspective', In: A. Gor Ze'ev (Ed), The end of academia in Israel? Haifa: University of Haifa.